Skip to main content

Book Review: Good to Great by James C. Collins


If you want to know how some ordinary companies transformed themselves to great (and big) then this is the book for you.

There are seven main ideas in the book, but not all of them were of interest to me. The four that were:

  1. Level 5 Leadership
  2. First Who, Then What
  3. The Stockdale Paradox
  4. Hedgehog Concept

Level 5 Leadership

CEO has to be humble but care deeply about the company. He has to find great people and trust them to do a great job. Charismatic CEO can't help the company, at least, in the long run. He may even leave it more fragile because he will take all the spotlight, fire managers that are too ambitious and is likely to rule with the iron fist. This will work for a short time but when he leaves there is no one to give orders and the company collapses. On the other hand, humble CEO uses best managers he can find, and tries to be as much dispensable as possible.


First Who, Then What

While hiring you can't make compromises. Every person you hire has to be great for the position. You can't sacrifice the quality of people for any reason, but his is not to say that you can't hire juniors or people without much experience, but you have to be sure if that person would fit into the organization. In case someone is not performing best organizations give that person several chances at different positions before they gave up on him. With great people on the board, they use the ideas of all employees to drive the company forward.

This point reminded me of classic quote:

The CFO asked: What if we invest in our people and they leave?
To which the CEO responded: What if we don’t and they stay?
Possible sources


The Stockdale Paradox

This chapter was interesting partly because of Mr. Stockdale history and the way you can use his mindset for your private life. Confront the brutal truth but never give up hope.

Hedgehog Concept

  1. What you are passionate about ("passion")?
  2. What could you be best in the world at ("best at")?
  3. What makes you money ("driving resource")?
The idea is very simple. If you can find something that answers all those questions this is the thing you should be doing. For me, it's probably programming. On the other hand, you should stop doing anything else. In my case, it might be blogging and reading business books... On the other hand, I know people that excel in many different disciplines and use knowledge from different domains to do great projects. There are also skills that help you with the main one. Writing and communication skills can help you even if you are a programmer. Basic knowledge about design and UX will help you write better prototypes and predict the requirements. 
Update: Interesting article about exact same problem appeared on Scott H. Young blog http://www.scotthyoung.com/blog/2015/04/07/paradoxical-virtues/

Unexpected

Surprisingly, I found it interesting to read about the history of big companies you can hear about every day. I have even learned how The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company come out of business. This one was just something I remember learning about in school and at that time wondering how it transitioned to our century. 


Overall I can recommend it to managers and leaders as I think they are going to learn most from the book. It is valuable also for the rest of us. Especially "The Stockdale Paradox" and "Hedgehog Concept" can be applied to the single person and single career. 

Rating: 6/10


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Course Review: The Bitfountain iOS 8 with Swift Immersive

This is second big iOS learning project. For first one read iOS Programming book review. As I only have two of them done I have to compare them somehow.

I am mindful that it took me a really long time to finish it (since last autumn). For a couple of months this year I didn't even have the internet to learn it, so it could not be helped. But last half of the June I've spent watching the videos every day and managed to finish it before any new internet problems.

So how was it?
In my opinion, it's great if you're starting out. There are a lot of basics, and seeing how to do things in XCode just makes your learning much easier than looking at the photos in the book. On the other hand, learning is more shallow and it is much easier to just follow the videos and learn only the basics without bigger picture about iOS SDK. I somehow missed more challenging exercises (even though I don't like to do them ;)

Length:
Course it pretty long but many videos are quite short (1-2…

How to Learn when Life is Short

I haven't really think this through but I have read really interesting articles recently and I just wanted to write for myself later.

Life is Short by Paul Graham

It's just that, learn from people older that you what is most important, and that life actually is short...

Instead of Goals or Resolutions, Try Creating Rules by Leo Babuta

In the time of New Year Resolutions, it's good to read something that is proposing different way of achieving things. Still I see much more value in habits than setting goals. But...

The Easy Way To Learn Hard Stuff by Per Harald Borgen
It's something that I read from time to time and I know it works sometimes for me. The things I learn then are really learned and something Jakub Wasilewski  has told me many times to do. Still it's uncomfortable and for some reason, I have failed to use this method more than once or twice. Writing it here so maybe I can think about it more and figure out how to do that more often.

Towards an understandin…

Hero's Journey in Presentations

Artur Skowroński recommended me: Want a Better Pitch? Watch This. by Andy Raskin and I think it is so great and applicable to all kinds of talks that I want to help it get more popular.
So the plan of presentation is going to follow these steps: Enemy - ProblemWhy now? - call to actionShow how the world will look like without the problemProblemsEvidence that you fixed the problem The image at the top is because it reminds me of Hero's Jurney. It has fewer steps but there is a lot of similarities. Especially #3 made me realize that grand vision of the future is something that I should have used in my talks.  The result at the start of the presentation makes a lot of sense actually. Everyone already knows that I speak about something because I probably fixed it and if you tell about it at the end then it might be hard for some people to see the bigger picture in the solution you're going to present.